Chris Wright, Toe Poke writerSep 8, 2023, 04:15 PM ET
Arsenal were recently forced to accept a heavy loss on the £72m club record fee they paid to sign Nicolas Pépé from French side Lille in the summer of 2019.
Indeed, after failing to fully ignite at the Emirates over the past four years, the wiry winger has joined Turkish Super Lig outfit Trabzonspor for a fraction of that initial price tag.
In Pepe leaving for pastures news, the Gunners have certainly suffered one of the most embarrassing financial forfeitures in recent top flight history but how does their worst ever transfer return compare to the rest of the Premier League — a league that is hardly famed for its financial prudence.
Here we examine the biggest losses made on players by all 20 clubs (in alphabetical order) currently playing in the elite division of English football and include those players who arrived in hefty deals only to have since left the team in question on a permanent basis (i.e. not currently out on loan).
Signed for £72m (Lille, Aug. 2019), moved for £3m (Trabzonspor, Sep. 2023)
Loss: £69m
Pepe offered up just 16 league goals and seven assists in 80 Premier League appearances for Arsenal, across three seasons. The French winger even scored 10 league goals during his much-improved second campaign (2020-21, so mostly behind closed doors) though it’s also worth noting that 4 of those goals came in the final two games of the schedule. After mustering just one solitary league goal in 20 games in his third season with the Gunners (2021-22), Pepe was sent out on loan at OGC Nice for the 2022-23 campaign before finally being freed up to move to Turkey on a permanent basis earlier this week.
Signed for £22.5m (Club Brugge, June 2019), released on free (June 2023)
Loss: £22.5m
Wesley scored a passable five league goals in 21 games during his debut season at Villa then quickly fell completely out of rotation. He made just three appearances in 2020-21, then one appearance in 2021-22 and then none at all in 2022-23 while enduring unremarkable loan stints with Brugge, Internacional and Levante. After being released by Villa, the Brazilian striker was signed by Championship side Stoke on a free transfer in July 2023.
Signed for £25m (Aug. 2018), moved on free (Crystal Palace, July 2023)
Loss: £25m
The Cherries’ joint-record signing played 176 league games in five seasons, scored 12 goals and was part of the squad that was both relegated from the Premier League in 2019-20 before winning promotion back to the top tier two seasons later. The Colombian international midfielder has since joined Crystal Palace on a free.
Signed for £5.5m (July 2019), moved on free (Malmo, July 2023)
Loss: £5.5m
With a shrewd approach to transfers that includes strong focus on potential resale value while evaluating their targets, Brentford don’t tend to lose a lot of money when it comes to their market dealings. To date, the Bees’ heaviest net loss came with the free transfer granted to veteran centre-back Jansson — the club’s 12th most expensive signing of all time — who returned to his native Sweden with Malmo over the summer.
Signed for £17m (from AZ, July 2018), moved for £850,000 (Feyenoord, July 2021)
Loss: £16.15m
After proving himself a goal-scoring threat in the Eredivisie, Iranian international striker Jahanbakhsh failed to find a convincing foothold with Brighton and ultimately departed without fanfare having scored just two goals in a half-century of Premier League games. However, the second of his goals just so happened to be an outrageous overhead kick against Chelsea in January of 2020 which was later voted Premier League Goal of the Month.
Signed for £13m (Norwich, Jan. 2017), moved on free (July 2021)
Loss: £13m
Republic of Ireland international Brady was signed for Norwich on deadline day in January 2017 for a then-club record fee. The winger spent five seasons at Turf Moor and contributed just four goals and three assists in 81 Premier League games before being allowed to leave on a free when his contract expired in July 2021, shortly after which he signed for Championship side Bournemouth on a free transfer.